
In the Chicago area, people are used to long periods of cold winter weather. As a result, drivers can encounter hazardous road conditions--caused by snow, freezing rain, or ice--from October all the way through April. Unfortunately, car accidents are much more likely to occur during these winter months when road conditions are not ideal. Most of us have figured out how to navigate winter weather without causing an accident, but sometimes, despite all our precautions, we can end up being struck by another vehicle that has lost control. When that happens, the driver responsible may feel that the collision was caused by the bad weather, but insurance companies need to determine liability regardless of bad weather.
If you have been injured in an accident caused by another vehicle in bad weather conditions, you may think that the insurance company will prove liability for you, but it is not advisable to rely on the insurance company alone. They may be hearing a completely different accident scenario from the other driver's insurance agent who wants to keep his company from having to pay compensation. We recommend that you contact an experienced car accident attorney to help you prove the other driver's liability so that you get compensated for your injuries. So, how is fault determined in a weather-related car accident?
When snow and ice are involved in a car accident, the police and the insurance companies will look at all the circumstances that may have contributed to the crash, including wintry weather and hazardous road conditions. However, just because a patch of ice causes a car to slide through an intersection and collide with another vehicle, does not mean that the driver of that car is not responsible. Far from it. Even when bad weather is a contributing factor in an accident, the driver who loses control and hits another vehicle is usually found to be liable. This is because the driver is expected to take preventive actions to avoid an accident. In inclement weather, it is the driver’s duty to slow down, keep a safe distance between his car and other vehicles, and drive in a manner that will allow him to keep control of his car no matter what the weather or road conditions. That is why drivers usually drive so slowly during the first snows of the winter. They are testing their car’s reaction to winter road conditions and being extra cautious to avoid an accident.
In every car accident, the insurance company must determine fault regardless of the weather. To do so, they investigate every factor involved: the driver’s speed, evasive maneuvers, distance from other vehicles, vehicle maintenance, brake usage, and whether the inclement weather was known or expected. They will get eyewitness accounts, record the drivers’ accounts of what occurred and who hit who, and look at evidence such as skid marks, position of the cars, and the location of vehicle damage to make their decision. As Naperville car accident attorneys, we will do our own investigation and collect this evidence independently to get a complete picture of the accident from our client’s perspective. This is critical if we want to refute statements made by the other driver and prove that he or she was responsible. If the other driver is found to have acted negligently and failed to use proper precautions in dangerous weather conditions, he or she will be found liable for damages. Some examples of driver negligence would include:
The driver could also be negligent because of poor vehicle maintenance such as:
If an accident occurs in bad weather and the insurance company can prove that the driver who caused the accident was negligent, then the outcome of the case will be similar to that of an accident that occurs in good weather conditions. If the driver responsible for an accident was using precautions and lost control anyway, the law still holds that driver accountable because he or she chose to drive in inclement weather and should have been able to drive in a way that allowed them to maintain control of the car.
Bad weather alone does not excuse a driver from responsibility. Illinois drivers are expected to adjust their speed and driving to the conditions, so a driver who fails to do so and causes a crash can still be found at fault. Liability depends on whether each driver acted reasonably for the conditions.
Generally, no. Drivers have a duty to operate their vehicles safely given the conditions. Claiming "the weather caused it" usually does not relieve a driver of liability if they were speeding, following too closely, or otherwise driving unsafely for the conditions.
Relevant factors include each driver's speed, following distance, use of headlights, tire condition, and whether they took reasonable precautions for the rain, snow, or ice. Evidence such as the police report, video, and witness accounts helps establish what each driver did.
Get to safety, call the police, and document the conditions and the scene with photos and video while it is fresh, since weather can change quickly. Seek medical care and keep records, and contact an attorney to help preserve evidence of the conditions.
Yes. Even in hazardous conditions, you can recover if another driver's failure to drive safely caused your injuries. Under Illinois comparative negligence (735 ILCS 5/2-1116), your recovery is reduced by any share of fault assigned to you, and barred only if you were more than 50% at fault.
Proving negligence in weather related accidents can be complicated; you need an experienced car accident attorney working for you. The car accident lawyers at Collins Law Group know how to prove negligence in these kinds of cases to ensure our clients are fairly compensated for their injuries. If you have been hit by another car in a weather-related accident and have been injured as a result, call us for a free evaluation of your case. Do not wait; the sooner we can begin gathering the evidence needed to prove the other driver was at fault, the better. Call us at (630) 527-1595 or fill out our contact form to protect your rights.
"*" indicates required fields











Chris G. was very professional and helpful!